Love fried eggs? The bread slices should be firm and thick. When the eggs begin to set around the edge of the hole, flip. When the eggs begin to set around the edge of the hole, flip. Finish cooking eggs as you prefer (over easy or over medium). Start with a loaf of good quality sandwich bread. Love fried eggs? It should be big enough to hold an egg in the middle. HOW TO MAKE EGGS IN A BASKET. Sprinkle eggs with salt and freshly ground pepper to taste. V for Vendetta's - Eggy in a Basket! Recipe by Kozmic Blues. ... Add a bit of butter to the center of the bread, and gently crack your eggs into the hole. This Egg In A Hole Breakfast Sandwich from Delish.com is the best! Sprinkle eggs with salt and freshly ground pepper to taste. This Egg In A Hole Breakfast Sandwich from Delish.com is the best! Really sharp edge cookie cutter, to get clean cut out, although the lid to a mason jar has worked for me as well. Use fresh eggs, preferably Organic eggs. Martha Stewart updates the traditional egg in a basket sandwich and shares her easy recipe.